Most Podcasters Are Optimizing the Wrong Number
- May 6
- 2 min read
By Jeffrey Frese
Download counts are the vanity metric of the audio world. They're the podcast equivalent of follower count: fun to screenshot, useless for paying your rent.
I'm Jeff Frese, founder of Eat My Face — a grass-fed tallow skincare brand I grew 10x year-over-year through audio and social content. I don't have a podcast. I have something better: a customer base that pays attention because we said something worth paying attention to.
Here's the strategic truth most creators skip over: attention is not the business. Conversion of attention into trust — and trust into transaction — is the business.
The 1,000 person test
If I gave you a choice between 1 million casual listeners who tuned out after 30 seconds, or 1,000 listeners who emailed you after every episode, bought everything you recommended, and told three friends about you — which would you take?
Every podcaster says "1,000." Almost none of them optimize for it.
They chase downloads. They obsess over charts. They add trending topics because the algorithm rewards it. And somewhere in that chase, they stop sounding like a real person with a real point of view — and start sounding like every other show in the feed.
The best podcasts feel like hanging with a friend who happens to solve a specific problem for you. Not a curated brand. A friend.
Parasocial is a feature, not a bug
The podcast industry is obsessed with "scaling intimacy." Translation: how do we feel personal to a million listeners without actually being personal?
You can't. And you shouldn't try.
The parasocial connection your audience feels is the single most valuable asset you have. It's also fragile. One bad sponsorship read for a product you don't actually use, and the trust cracks. Once it cracks, it doesn't come back — it leaks out as unsubscribes over weeks.
Our brand didn't grow from big reach.
It grew from showing up consistently, being uncomfortably honest about our product, and building real relationships with the people already listening. 10x growth wasn't because we chased audience. It was because we honored the audience we had.
Monetization isn't separate from content
Here's where most creators break their business: they treat monetization as a phase that happens after they "build an audience." Wrong.
Monetization is woven in from day one, or it will feel bolted-on when you finally try it. The creators who convert best were always clear about what they sell, who they serve, and what problem they solve. Their product wasn't a surprise. It was the logical outcome of everything they'd already said.
If your audience is shocked when you sell them something, you built the wrong relationship.
The unglamorous playbook
The strategy that actually works: Be radically clear about who you're talking to. Say something only you could say. Show up every week, even when the data is ugly. Sell something your listeners genuinely want, not whatever sponsor pays you. Treat your audience like partners, not product.
None of this is revolutionary. All of it works.
Stop optimizing for a bigger number. Start optimizing for a better one.
Connect With Jeffrey
Comments